Everton find themselves in a familiar yet frustrating position heading into the middle of September. With the summer transfer window long closed, David Moyes has just one senior recognised centre-forward at his disposal in Thierno Barry. The situation stems directly from deadline day chaos that saw a deal for Folarin Balogun collapse after a medical issue and renegotiations with Monaco.
The 23-year-old American international was poised to join on a permanent basis, with a deal sheet even submitted, but ultimately flew back without signing. Beto’s sale to Fiorentina for a reported £15m compounded the issue, leaving the squad threadbare in attack. Moyes has been candid about the lack of depth, stating bluntly that he does not have enough players for a full Premier League campaign.
This has sparked renewed interest in the free agent market. Mauro Icardi, the 33-year-old Argentine with 77 career goals across spells at Inter Milan and Galatasaray, has emerged as a potential target. Reports from ESPN journalist Luiz Carlos Largo highlighted Everton as one option for the experienced forward, whose contract expired at the end of last season. Icardi would bring proven Premier League quality on a short-term deal, offering an immediate antidote to the glaring shortage.
Yet The Athletic’s Patrick Boyland has poured cold water on expectations, noting structural reasons why Everton are unlikely to pursue free agents aggressively. Financial prudence under the Friedkin Group ownership remains paramount, with player trading central to their model. Recent sales, including Nathan Patterson, Iliman Ndiaye and Tim Iroegbunam for a combined £80m, helped satisfy liquidity rules, but further outlay requires careful calibration.
The timing adds pressure. Everton sit ninth in the Premier League after four matches, showing resilience with late equalisers in recent games thanks in part to new signing Ainsley Maitland-Niles. His arrival from Lyon has already paid dividends, but the forward line needs reinforcement to sustain momentum. Fans, already vocal about summer frustrations, will watch closely for any movement on Icardi or alternatives before the next window.
Moyes faces a test of squad management in the short term, with the Carabao Cup tie against Wolves providing an early opportunity to blood youngsters. The club’s ability to navigate this striker shortfall without panic will define the coming weeks, especially as ownership explores potential new investment to bolster resources.

